Moving a restaurant from Toast to Square without retyping the menu

Updated November 12, 2026 · 6 min read

When a restaurant moves from Toast to Square, the menu is the job nobody wants. Toast and Square don't share a format, neither will import the other's file, and a full menu with sizes and add-ons is a long day of typing. You don't have to retype it.

Step 1: Get the menu out of Toast

Pick whichever of these you can get:

  • A Toast menu export. Toast Web can export menu data to CSV. It's the cleanest source because names and prices are already exact. Ask the owner to pull it before the Toast account is closed.
  • The printed or PDF menu. Usually close to the POS, but check for items that are only on the register (add-ons, "open food", staff items).
  • Photos of the register screens. Not pretty, but it catches modifiers that aren't on the printed menu.
  • Screenshots of the restaurant's online ordering page. Good for modifier detail. Screenshot it; don't rely on link-import tools that scrape delivery apps.

Do this before the Toast contract ends. Once the account is closed, the export is gone.

Step 2: Translate Toast's structure to Square's

In ToastIn Square
Menu groupCategory
Menu itemItem
Size (size pricing or a size modifier group)Variations on the item (one row each)
Modifier group (required, min/max)Modifier set (min/max set in Square)
Open price / market priceVariable price

The one that bites: in Toast, sizes are often a modifier group. In Square they should usually be variations, so reporting and inventory work per size. Convert them, don't copy them as modifiers.

Step 3: Build the Square file

Square's item import is one row per variation. It can switch modifier sets on per item, but it can't create them. So:

  1. Create each modifier set in Square (Items → Modifiers), exact names, options, prices and min/max.
  2. Download the item import template from the Square account.
  3. Fill in items and variations, and mark Y on the modifier set columns each item uses.
  4. Import with Replace library on a fresh account (or Modify if items already exist).

Full detail in our Square item library import guide.

Step 4: Check before go-live

  • Item count and category count match the old menu.
  • Spot-check 10 prices, including every size of one drink.
  • Ring a test order with each required modifier set to make sure it prompts.
  • Set up taxes, and check alcohol is taxed correctly.
  • Rebuild kitchen printer routing; it doesn't come across.

The fast way

Upload the Toast export or photos of the menu to Fast POS Menu, pick Square, and it does the translation in step 2 for you: sizes to variations, groups to modifier sets with min/max, categories in menu order. Review anything flagged, then download the Square item sheet and your modifier set checklist.

Going the other way, or to Clover? Same tool, different output. See switching POS without retyping the menu.

Menu labels and import rules are as of the date above and can change. Square, Clover and Toast are trademarks of their respective owners. Fast POS Menu is independent and not affiliated with or endorsed by them. Our import files are in beta while we confirm them against real accounts.

Move the menu, not the keyboard.

Toast export or photos in. Square import file out. $49.